Most cancers affected person sues UCSD Health over 500K-chronicle data breach

A affected person in El Cajon, California, sued College of California, San Diego Health this past week over a security breach that doubtlessly uncovered the non-public data of 495,949 sufferers.  

The plaintiff, Denise Menezes, is elevating allegations of negligence, breach of contract, breach of self assurance, and the violation of California’s authorized pointers about clinical privateness and unfair competition.   

She is searching out for sophistication-action space.  

“The guidelines breach occurred as a result of UC San Diego Health did no longer enforce reasonable safety procedures and practices, did no longer present its workers with classic cybersecurity coaching designed to forestall ‘phishing’ attacks, did no longer settle enough steps to note for and detect extraordinary exercise on its servers, did no longer characterize fabric info surrounding its melancholy data safety protocols and did no longer effectively timed voice the victims of the info breach,” read the complaint, which used to be filed in California federal court docket.

UC San Diego Health representatives stated the university can no longer touch upon pending litigation. 


In accordance to the complaint, Menezes is being handled for breast most cancers at UC San Diego Health’s Moores Most cancers Heart.

In September 2021, she received a look informing her that she used to be among the sufferers whose data – including, in her case, fleshy title, claims data, clinical chronicle quantity and remedy data – had been uncovered in a phishing incident

In accordance to UC San Diego Health, the hackers might perchance maybe possess had gain entry to to personal data for months.  

Aloof, “UC San Diego Health’s letter created more questions than it answered,” essentially essentially essentially based on the complaint.  

Menezes’ attorneys voice UC San Diego Health waited months to gain entangled with person sufferers, no subject publishing a total look about the incident in June.  

“Obviously, a internet space posting did no longer title which explain sufferers had been impacted and used to be inadequate to affirmatively alert people impacted by the info breach to settle measures to guard themselves,” stated the complaint.  

They furthermore voice the letter is “downplaying the possibility of misuse,” and missing key data about the incident or the hackers’ identities.  

“On account of the info breach, Ms. Menezes has hung out and effort researching the breach and reviewing her financial and clinical tale statements for evidence of unauthorized exercise, which she’s going to continue to attain for years into the long trail,” stated the complaint.  

The complaint says that UC San Diego did no longer follow classic ideas and pointers that would possess prevented the breach from happening, stressing the negative consequences of clinical identification theft.  

“Each data breach will increase the chance that a victim’s personal data will seemingly be uncovered to more people who’re searching out for to misuse it at the victim’s expense,” stated the complaint.  

“Now that the investigation is entire, notifications to people whose data used to be impacted had been despatched starting up September 7, 2021, on a rolling foundation the place contact data used to be on hand,” stated UC San Diego Health representatives essentially essentially essentially based on a expect of for comment.

“UC San Diego Health labored deliberately, whereas taking care to present correct data, as immediate as it might perchance maybe,” they added, noting that the university arranged for oldsters whose data used to be impacted to receive one twelve months of free credit ranking monitoring and identification theft protection products and services thru IDX.

“Moreover these actions, UC San Diego Health began taking remediation measures to increase their safety controls which possess integrated, among completely different steps, altering employee credentials, disabling gain entry to aspects, and making improvements to safety processes and procedures,” stated the representatives. “Whereas there are moderately a couple of safeguards in place to guard data from unauthorized gain entry to, UC San Diego Health is furthermore always working to present a enhance to them so we are able to additional sever encourage the possibility of this form of possibility exercise.”


The lawsuit is proof that for effectively being programs who’re victimized by cyberattacks, the financial fallout can transcend paying a ransom (something the feds restful present in opposition to) or having to terminate procedures.  

And UC San Diego Health is rarely with out a doubt on my own. Earlier this twelve months, Scripps Health, furthermore in San Diego, confronted a handful of fits after a ransomware incident resulted in a weeks-long community shutdown.  


Menezes “suffered emotional anguish vivid that her extremely personal clinical and remedy data is now on hand to criminals to commit blackmail, extortion, clinical-connected identification theft or fraud, and any quantity of additional harms in opposition to her for the remainder of her existence,” essentially essentially essentially based on the complaint.

Kat Jercich is senior editor of Healthcare IT News.

Twitter: @kjercich

Email: [email protected]

Healthcare IT News is a HIMSS Media e-newsletter.

Content Protection by

Back to top button