MAILBOX: Umthokozo wa’ McIntosh – renaming at UCT

South Africa’s longest-serving flesh presser, Graham McIntosh, with subtle humour and traditionally impeccable manners, motivates for the fastidiously thought-out renaming (or no longer) of three constructions on the University of Cape Town campus. Likely driven by apprehension the outcomes of the consultative course of by the ‘Naming of Constructions Committee’, will insist politically appropriate newest ruling ideology, he comes up with some sudden solutions with deep ties to, and that method, for the splendidly diverse UCT alumni. It’s in his motivation for these that he offers a mirror to the schisms in world views held by South Africans across the used and fresh orders. It is tempting to imply that, on steadiness, the names he places forward would get favour with a important piece of the alumni and keep less divisive and more reflective of our rich historical past than what’s going to doubtlessly transpire. We’ll quickly discover. The time limit used to be Monday. With a bit of of luck his enter made it. This text used to be first published on Politicsweb.– Chris Bateman

Umthokozo (respectfully grateful – verb)

---

Renaming at UCT: Some solutions

By Graham McIntosh

“Ful ofte in sport, a sooth I gain, hears saye!” Chaucer 1390. —  “Don’t be mad with this fellow, I protest that many a first rate observe hath been spoke in jest” (Roxburghe Ballads Version 1847). — “Many a first rate observe is spoken in jest”. (Eminem 1 Might maybe well well 2018).

Hello my glowing Kgethi.

I expertise your welcoming informality on your “From Kgethi” invitation for proposals for the Renaming of areas and areas on our Upper Campus on your 17 November UCT Publication. I grew up with khuleka (wait courteously) and thakazelas (honorific clan names) but I’m adapting to your newest politically appropriate, if fresh for me, cultural style.

I majored in Social Anthropology below Professor Monica Wilson who taught me the importance and value of culture and customs in our societies. I thus recognise diversified cultural practices and treat all of them with respect. I the truth is savor your friendly portrait – ‘Ntombi elihle’ (glowing girl), as our wholesome and active inclined President, and unrivalled national ‘soga’ (Casanova), Jacob Zuma, directly would gain celebrated.

I produce desire to thanks for you graciousness and transparency in asking your University trained community (all of us, fortunately, don’t gain completely a matric exemption) “to insist deeply about who and what the University represents” as we form proposals to your NoBC (Naming of Constructions Committee). I gain already made my three short submissions and thanks for acknowledging, digitally, the receipt of them.

I’m fully licensed to touch upon what UCT “represents”, attributable to I’m an Alumnus (1961-1964) of the University and grateful for the education I enjoyed there. that it used to be founded in 1829 (Karl Marx used to be completely a boy of eleven) and that you just help within the shadow (isithunzi) of an unparalleled custom of leadership and provider of the Principals after which VC (Vice-Chancellor) who came old to you.

I indubitably veritably “insist deeply“ about UCT. The crucial discipline for coaching one to insist, is, pointless to claim, Philosophy. My one 300 and sixty five days of Philosophy used to be sitting on the feet of Professor Andrew Murray (1962) and he stretched my thoughts to coach me to price rationality. Your very luxuriate in Professor of Philosophy is the well-known David Benatar whose most newest guide has reminded us of the roots and significance of our extensive establishment.

Dangle you ever read his guide, Kgethi? To form it more straightforward for busy of us to take to this point there is a short review by William Gild and published on Politicsweb.co.za and coincidentally on the identical date as your newsletter.

Nonetheless let me get help to the NoBC to whom I gain steered names for every of the three localities you may maybe likely want nominated for naming in Smuts Corridor, Madiba Circle, Jameson Plaza. I desire to amplify on my reasoning and additionally to imply diversified names that that you just may maybe pigeonhole for future use round our University.

On SMUTS HALL, no alternate. Anybody, including myself, who reads of Smuts’ intellectual and diversified achievements can’t get away without a sense of awe and astonishment. South African soil produced even handed one of the critical extensive leaders, intellects and squaddies of the Twentieth Century.

All South Africans may maybe additionally additionally be proud of Smuts and UCT may maybe additionally simply restful be to boot. These trying to airbrush him out of historical past must gain deep inferiority complexes, if they gain even read anything referring to the person. I gain seconded a Motion to head old to the Convocation meeting in December 2021 on the matter.

MADIBA CIRCLE may maybe additionally simply restful honour the well-known and tender Professor Bongani Manyosi and be identified as Manyosi Circle. He used to be so deeply distressed and sorrowful by the violent conduct of the Rhodes Must Tumble leaders in Andile Mngxitama and Julius Malema that he took his luxuriate in lifestyles on 27 July 2018.

Honouring a blinding academic, who died so tragically, is what UCT may maybe additionally simply restful produce. A plaque with factual wording must recognise his outstanding academic success to boot to show why he took his lifestyles. Including the names of the Rhodes Must Tumble instigators on the plaque may maybe additionally simply restful additionally be regarded as.

JAMESON PLAZA may maybe additionally simply restful be named Helen Zille Plaza. She helped, as a Rand Day-to-day Mail journalist, to negate that Steve Biko died from being assaulted and tortured by the Particular Branch in Port Elizabeth. In 2009 she ran the DA Election campaign with the “Discontinuance Zuma” slogan.

She used to be an important Mayor of Cape Town and the first female Premier of a Province. She led the Western Cape, the keep UCT is located, to turn out to be a mannequin of factual governance.  Furthermore, her outstanding role within the DA’s achievements, in basically the most newest Local Government Elections, is “the writing on the wall” that’s repulsive the SACP/ANC because it did Belshazzar when Daniel interpreted the writing to him that “God has numbered his days and he has been weighed and learned looking out”.

To gain been the kind of dogged, determined, damsel over all these years deserves recognition. She has no hobby in and does no longer may maybe additionally simply restful be patronised by “genderists”. She has intellectual muscle which UCT may maybe additionally simply restful applaud. Her most newest guide, “#Protect Woke” is no longer the the truth is guide that she has written and, as a journalist she is and has been a prolific wordsmith.

Four more names that I’d snatch to imply for the NoBC to assign in thoughts the use of at some stage are Reverend Tiyo Soga, Professor Jack Simons, Professor Monica Wilson and Prophet Nongqawuse.

Reverend Tiyo Soga used to be an unparalleled mind and used to be recognised as such by William Govan the first Critical of Lovedale Faculty in Alice, Eastern Cape. Soga used to be despatched to Scotland for university education, the keep he excelled and learned his Scottish companion.  He returned to the Eastern Cape but died younger from tuberculosis.

He is a blinding role mannequin for any pupil striving for excellence, as you seem to gain done on your luxuriate in academic occupation, and heaps more appropriate for a blinding academic establishment, than the irregular selection of Sarah Baartman Corridor. Her Memorial in her Hankey Mission Inform is the appropriate spot to honour her. Sadly it is miles uncompleted and likely a sufferer of the ANC’s incompetence and ubiquitous soft corruption.

Prof Jack Simons lectured me in CAGL (Comparative African Government and Law) in 1961.  A memorable comment in his thick Afrikaans accent (at his funeral Charles Nqakula reminded of us of his humility and that he veritably described himself as simply a “plaas japie” from Riversdal), to our class on one occasion used to be, “Beget into yarn students that if you happen to don’t gain a historical past, you may maybe likely frequently form one”.

Presumably it is miles this Marxist Revisionism that NoBC embraces. With a bit of of luck you don’t, Kgethi. He used to be a member of the KGB, used to be awarded the Lenin Prize for loyalty to the Soviet Union, used to be a teacher of Marxism-Leninism within the ANC/MK camps in Africa including Solomon Mahlangu in Tanzania and the notorious Quattro in Angola.

We had been additionally blood-associated as our Moms’ surname used to be Morkel. Your entire Morkels in Southern Africa are descended from one male ancestor, Philip Morkel, who came to the Cape in 1708 as a worker for a world firm bigger than Microsoft, namely the Dutch East India Company. UCT may maybe additionally simply restful recognise Jack Simons in a technique.

Professor Monica Wilson used to be an improbable teacher, academic and researcher and a pioneer in being a female in that spot. One of her sons is Emeritus Professor Francis Wilson who has done crucial work and analysis round poverty.  Dr Tim Wilson is the diversified son and he married Ilse Fischer — she and I had been fellow students — whose father used to be Bram Fischer, who, savor Jack Simons, used to be a Communist.

The fourth person and a gloomy female, for the NoBC to assign in thoughts recognising is Nongqawuse from Centane, Eastern Cape whose visions and prophecies generated the Xhosa cattle killing 1856-7 and resultant famine and impoverishment of that piece of inhabitants of the Eastern Cape Colony. Some gain wittily steered that our newest day Nongqawuse is the blackouts from ESKOM coming up from the ANC’s visions and delusions.

I do know that you just, collectively with your dedication to transparency and consultation, will no longer object that this correspondence is regarded by me as an “open letter”.

Sinifisela nhlanhla (Alles van die beste),

Graham McIntosh

---

Renaming of upper campus areas and areas

Learn more:

• When anarchists dominated – UCT’s Fallist instances
• Remembering two extensive South Africans currently lost to suicide
• Reflections on suicide of Professor Bongani Mayosi, persecuted to death – Ed Herbst

(Visited 5,141 instances, 21 visits currently)