Peter Well-known on Northam intercepting Impala Platinum’s target

Used mining analyst Peter Well-known analyses Royal Bafokeng Platinum’s resolution to reject Impala Platinum’s takeover present, opting for a take care of Northam Platinum in its set. In a deal valued at around R17bn, Northam Platinum will capture a third of RBP at R180.50 per share, a 50% top price on its share mark prior to the deal used to be announced. Strangely, RBP’s share mark fell following the announcement. Northam’s slumped 15%, on a day the set the producer of treasured metals lost bigger than R10bn. At face value, Well-known says the consolidation of Impala and RBP made heaps of sense given the operational synergies. Well-known is more sceptical with synergies and benefits of consolidation with Northam; on the opposite hand, he outlines that Northam CEO Paul Dunne is a shrewd operator and has intentions to scale the industry to phases which are handsome for international funding homes. – Justin Rowe-Roberts

On Northam Platinum buying a 33% stake in Royal Bafokeng: 

Effectively, it appears to me adore a case of cash talks. Must you gaze the value that Paul Dunne is spellbinding to pay, I’m able to gaze why Royal Bafokeng Platinum determined to head with somebody else. It looks adore a minute little bit of a crazy mark but I explain this isn’t appropriate a cash deal, it’s a share deal as smartly. And if you’re speaking mark to earnings (PE), Northern Platinum is buying and selling on practically double the PE that Lonmin (obtained by Sibanye-Stillwater) is. It’s buying and selling at double the PE that RBP is buying and selling on. That’s more or less the establish of the game. Must you would possibly perchance perchance perchance per chance perchance use excessive priced paper to rob an asset at a decrease mark, that’s going to supply you similar earnings; you would possibly perchance perchance perchance per chance perchance make clear it adore that, I maintain Paul [Dunne] can. And Paul obviously has bigger ambitions than appropriate running Northam and Booysendal [mines]. I wouldn’t doubt he’s got visions to position the two companies collectively within the future in one itemizing.

On the causes for Royal Bafokeng’s share mark decline: 

That I’m able to’t in actual fact masks, yet; except they appropriate think the Northam mark goes to reach relieve down so great that once they catch the shares, it’s going to be countered. When Impala announced a deal, it wasn’t on the discipline of as juicy. You saw it hotfoot up adore 20% in at some point. I haven’t worked thru the numbers yet. The market’s very ambiance pleasant but you would possibly perchance perchance perchance per chance perchance also gaze the Northam mark. It dropped about 9% or 10%. Then it dropped as minute as 16% and went relieve to about 11%. Now it’s down 15%. Moderately a pair of guys are doing varied permutations. Then whatever numbers you’re doing on the companies, you want search over your shoulder and question: what’s my seek for of the commodity mark?

On whether or no longer the deal makes more sense for Northam or Impala: 

That’s no longer very obvious. It’s in actual fact varied. I used to be very shocked to search this. Impala’s share mark dropped when they announced this but you didn’t need to search at it very intently to [realise] medium timeframe, right here’s an exact deal. Longer timeframe, it’s a worthy deal. I maintain it used to be an exact deal for every events. RBP would had been entering into Impala shares but it completely in actual fact made sense for Impala. It seemed far more handsome for Impala than it used to be RBP. It used to be increasing a dynamo, a spacious participant and heaps of of us hang stated RBP is no longer any longer going to be on its enjoy for one other few years, at the most. It used to be straight forward to search the synergies. Impala used to be moral next to RBP. It had the smelter preparations, the refinery, it had the marketing, logistics and they were neighbours. You would possibly perchance perchance perchance per chance perchance tick heaps of containers. This made precise sense. Whereas with Northam, they’re a long potential off and Northam doesn’t hang the refining capabilities that Impala does.

On why South African miners are priced at a minimize mark relative to global counterparts: 

Certainly, we regarded all over the water for decades and at companies we thought weren’t on the discipline of as smartly bustle as ours (South African mines). That never perceived to hang a balance sheet adore ours and no longer incessantly ever had the more or less resources we hang got. It wasn’t attributable to infrastructure. It wasn’t attributable to the weather or deposits. We’ve got improbable weather right here. Implausible ore deposits. We now hang an exact infrastructure. We had all the pieces right here for long-lifestyles mines, with the exception of we had apartheid. We had a government that wasn’t ready to masks investors the potential out. It wasn’t a democratically elected government [so we knew it couldn’t] remaining and none of us would possibly perchance perchance perchance per chance wait. We were in this form of streak for 1994. We were hoping it used to be going to be in ‘84 and ‘87. We were continuously praying it used to be going to be this year or this year and when it at remaining came, it hasn’t translated to what any of us principal.

Read also: 

• Peter Well-known provides Impala’s takeover of Royal Bafokeng Platinum the thumbs up
• ‘AngloGold shareholders are one of the precious most affected person on the JSE’ – Peter Well-known as commodity cycle turns
• Commodity costs are unsustainable at these phases – Peter Well-known rings the terror bells

(Visited 579 events, 11 visits as of late)