The exhausting-hitting Magnus Heystek begins the year questioning the sustainability of the industrial stipulations in South Africa. The past 10 years South Africa has vastly below performed relative to global markets, with the JSE All Fragment Index mountaineering a mere 3% per annum. This whereas global markets, particularly the US indices, have confidence been mountaineering in excess of 15% per annum in what has been a goldilocks skills for equity markets. South Africans are poorer as of late than they’ve ever been relative to the comfort of the sphere. Magnus also touches shut to emigration, which is increasingly more unaffordable for South Africans, given the consistent weakening of the rand. – Justin Rowe-Roberts
Table of Contents
Will our Decennium Horribilis flip into a Vicennium Horribilis?
By Magnus Heystek*
IT became in 1992 that Queen Elizabeth, head of the British monarchy, having a check support at the year correct passed, uttered these infamous phrases:
“1992 is now not a year to which I shall look for support with undiluted pleasure … it has grew to develop into out to be an annus horribilis.”
She became, for sure, exasperated by the things her children have confidence been taking into account including Prince Charles, Princess Ann and even in these years Prince Andrew.
Queen Elizabeth is now not the monarch of the Republic of South Africa, nevertheless if she have confidence been, she would with out a doubt have confidence been entitled to touch upon the “decennium horribilis” which her historic colony had to undergo over the decade 2011-2021.
For these which will be even worse at Latin than me, decennium refers to a period of 10 years or a decade. Vicennium – heaven forbid – refers to 2 a protracted time.
For honest about all South Africans the decade from 2011 to 2021 has been nasty, a financial, political and economic blow out of virtually unheard of fluctuate and get. And with out pressing and reasonably primary adjustments to the vogue the economic system is being managed, attain we speed the probability of experiencing but some other decade of such financial and societal give map. Slowly nevertheless with out a doubt.
As I strive to gift, with out the ANC out of vitality and far from any spigot of express/provincial or municipal money, may per chance well we sink even deeper into the morass, heading nearer to being a failed express. I admire a form of political commentators are confidently forecasting that the ANC will likely be long gone after the election in 2024 (Dr. Piet Croucamp, amongst others), nevertheless I am now not so definite. I feel anybody who thinks the ANC is correct going to hand over vitality and slink away into political oblivion lives in cloud-cuckoo land. An ANC/EFF-tie up is a definite bet and with that, far more political looting of express and civil coffers to feed the hungry beast.
Soccer World Cup aftermath
However let’s bolt support to 2011 to get a approach of how far we have fallen in this kind of short intention of time. When the calendar flipped over into 1st January 2011 we have confidence been gentle basking within the after-glow of hosting the vastly successful Soccer World Cup in 2010 with the closing taking assemble on 11 July 2010.
Our nation became awash with foreign tourists, we have confidence been the media-darling of more than correct the sporting world and as South Africans we have confidence been also quietly very cocky and assured that we managed to pull off the largest sporting tournament within the sphere with out a first-rate subject.
Waka Waka: This became our time. Near 2011 and come in some unspecified time in the future.
The economic system became rising very solidly, SA had an investment ranking from the total three main credit rating agencies and a complete lot of the main financial indicators have confidence been flashing a usual green, with reasonably bit of amber here and here. The JSE in actuality had a extremely perfect year in 2011 and became no doubt one of many discontinue-performing markets within the sphere.
A mere 10 years later and nearly ALL these indicators are flashing crimson or amber. The ANC govt is outwardly oblivious to the strident calls from global agencies, similar to the Worldwide Monetary Fund (IMF) which as recently as this week (again) urged the government to put in force radical adjustments to the vogue to economic system is managed.
Time and intention does now not allow a chubby breakdown and analysis of how we featured on the total main economic indicators from 2011 to end 2021. Factual read my articles going support to 2013 on this and other web sites. It’s all there in murky and white.
Let’s bewitch the rand/greenback commerce for starters.
In January 2011 I may per chance well with R1m bewitch myself $134,000. This present day, this kind of transaction will only save $64,000 into my pocket. As an importer I pay up to now more for my goods or, I correct get loads much less for the identical amount of money. Not by an inflation-adjusted low cost, nevertheless by a broad decline of more than 50% in decrease than a decade.
Ten years within the past I may per chance well potentially have confidence adequate money a median house within the US with my R1m. This present day, to the drop in rate of the rand and soaring US property costs, I will only bewitch a quarter of the dwelling, or thereabouts.
Lest one thinks that it only effects the smartly-to-attain, that is exclusively now not the case. From the prosperous to the unhappy pay more for any imported goods similar to oil/petrol/diesel, clinical devices, cell telephones, motor automobiles and the savor.
The rate of motor automobiles has been rising at double the inflation payment for over 40 years now, which is one reason why annual novel automobile sales has been on a decade prolonged-decline.
The performance of the JSE also began to whisper no in opposition to the comfort of the sphere. First, this below-performance became in opposition to the roaring developed market stock indices, Wall Aspect street in particular, nevertheless also in contemporary years in opposition to its emerging markets peers. Let’s bewitch the identical R1m 10 years or so within the past. Briefly, over a 10 year period the JSE has returned correct over 3% per annum whereas the S&P 500 as been rising at 16% per annum over the identical time. The MSCI world index grew by 13% per annum over the identical time.
R1m invested into the Allan Grey Equity fund in January 2012 affords me an amount of R2.5m. Not unsightly, nevertheless only giving you support your money after inflation and charges. The identical investment within the Franklin US Opportunities fund, a US basically basically based equity fund as of late affords you R9.8m in your pocket. That you just would be in a position to well per chance bewitch almost 4 times the dwelling/automobile/luxury goods than that you may per chance also as of late when in contrast to SA’s largest equity fund.
And if you happen to had the foresight to invest 100% into the Nasdaq your R1m would have confidence grew to develop into into R15.7m as of late.
On the beginning it became performance only, nevertheless within the 2d half of the decade correct passed, something more ominous started going down: novel listings on JSE nearly dried up whereas a spacious – scale delisting of firms started, within the foundation reasonably dinky, nevertheless which has since then grew to develop into into a torrent. Over the last decade about 143 JSE-listed firms have confidence both delisted or moved their listings in numerous locations.
This has came about within the course of a raging global bull market (2009 up to now) and with literally hundreds of novel listings all over the sphere all over the identical time. International merchants have confidence also been heading for the hills, with about R650bn transferring out of the JSE over the past 5 years.
Bonfire of unsightly news
What can I add to this bonfire of unsightly news over the past decade?
- SA’s relate payment has dropped to a median of 1,2% per annum, the lowest common returns begin air of a world battle explain.
- SA’s unemployment payment has risen from an already high 23% of inhabitants in 2011 to 42% as of late. In all, more other folks as of late are unemployed than these which will be employed..
- The sequence of oldsters receiving some more or much less express-aid is now in excess of 18 m other folks.
- A smartly-liked income grant for all is on the cards.
- Big swathes of the nation’s infrastructure has already been destroyed including our rail network which, in years long gone by, became basically the easiest in Africa. Eskom’s debt is now in excess of R400bn whereas Allege Owned Carrying out’s debt has ballooned to R692bn by December 2021.
- SA’s national debt owed by govt is R3,92trn as of as of late, almost R1trn more than correct two years within the past..
- SA’s commercial and industrial property markets have confidence now shown zero relate in 10 years, courtesy of collapsing municipal infrastructure and with out warning rising administered costs by municipalities all over the nation. Lesser-suggested and friends and household severely doubt me when I imprint that the designate of our perfect-looking (some of them) having a check centres scattered all over the nation’s main cities, have confidence skilled declines in rate ranging from between 30% and 80% in some conditions.
- The return on SA’s pension and privately managed retirement funds have confidence been strangled by an antiquated regulatory system (reg28) which prescribes a most of 30% offshore (currently; it became 25% till recently.) The tip end result up to now (Reg 28 became equipped in 2010) is that the majority participants of these pension funds have confidence needed to be command with returns barely beating inflation after all costs and costs have confidence been deducted. This whereas the comfort of the sphere has enjoyed a spacious stock market relate since 2010. Add to that equation the relate in residential property costs all over the sphere (US residential property costs have confidence, on common, double over the past 10 years),
The SA residential property market, by comparison, has been moribund with common costs exhibiting declines in exact phrases of about 23% for the explanation that peak in 2008 (Source FNB Barometer) and by about 55% when costs in US dollars.
Briefly: SA and its other folks has develop into very unhappy in per capita phrases, whereas even the so-known as prosperous have confidence suffered a intriguing decline in global procuring vitality except that have confidence moved a spacious deal of their money offshore or into asset swap funds.
To to migrate or now not?
That brings me to my final level: emigration. After the July riots in KZN/Gauteng I and potentially many wealth managers all over the nation have confidence had some excessive classes with their HNW purchasers about upping and leaving. And I feel many of these discussions have confidence ended with the realisation that (a) except there are some familial links to a nation, most countries within the sphere in actuality don’t desire South Africans and have confidence been hanging up obstacles to entry (Current Zealand / Australia / Canada and so forth.)
Along with, even a fortune of whisper R50m to R100m in South African phrases, does now not bolt away you with a lot after you’ve equipped a house or house, two automobiles and capital to fund a monthly income of whisper $5,000 per month. Hobby rates are zero, meaning it is foremost to map down from you’re your capital, both in SA or in a foreign nation. A stock market decline of 20-40% will mercurial wipe out a form of that capital, making the numbers far more unimaginable.
I don’t have confidence any statistics to support me up as but, nevertheless I feel the broad outflow of High-Rep-Price Folks (HNWI’s) has slowed down considerably. As a replacement, the western and southern Cape has develop into the bolt-to areas for affluent other folks and their families wanting to flee the give map of virtually every thing within the north of the nation.
For the 2d year working I have confidence been spending my Yuletide-spoil at my house at Val de Vie correct begin air Paarl, potentially the premier residential estate in SA.
I have confidence spent many a day within the pool or gym chatting to “inkommers” – newly arrived fellow South Africans getting within the estate, if they’ll assemble something to bewitch. It in actuality feels surreal nevertheless the builders have confidence nearly speed out of land to promote whereas there’s a glide for condo homes.
I am on the total equipped R25,000 per month and more for my 2-bedroomed house, which in Johannesburg or Pretoria may per chance have confidence adequate money you a mansion on no doubt one of many a form of over-developed golf estates. However other folks and their families grab to be within the Paarl intention with its spacious colleges and a bunch of outdoor activities.
It appears to me that the novel Realizing B is to bolt to the Western/Southern Cape whereas getting as a lot investments offshore as imaginable, leaving adequate in SA bonds or enhanced income funds for income-necessities. The map in which of living SA affords – mostly within the western Cape are gentle incomparable to what’s likely to be enjoyed and afforded in numerous locations within the sphere.
Youthful other folks, especially educated ones with their younger families, are gentle heading offshore in spacious numbers, nevertheless they haven’t made their fortunes as but and would also are seeking to search out the sphere and its alternatives. Many will bolt away, some would per chance also come support.
The following 10 years
Ten years is a actually prolonged time and I don’t have confidence any clue what the Royal household will get as a lot as. The ANC, on the opposite hand is far more predictable and I provide the following:
This would per chance also honest strive to develop its spending to quit in vitality or attain a address the EFF and it may per chance per chance well gentle be triumphant but some other time at the 2024 smartly-liked election. Then the already unsightly express of SA’s finances and infrastructure will bolt into a free tumble. I have confidence develop into particularly bearish on the foreign money because it has remained reasonably stable (surprisingly) over the past 5 years or so, nevertheless a tightening of US quantitative easing with higher hobby rates globally, may per chance well effort the rand bulls very shortly.
Don’t wait too prolonged to put in force the exact PLAN B shortly. That different may per chance even be long gone very shortly.
*Magnus Heystek is investment strategist at Brenthurst Wealth (www.bwm.co.za). That you just would be in a position to well per chance apply him on twitter @magnusheystek.
Read also:
- Handiest of 2021: Magnus Heystek on the JSE and why you’ve suffered financial wipe-out
- Handiest of 2021: ‘Govt’s intentions with the pension fund amendments are ominous’ – Magnus Heystek
- Handiest of 2021: The trillion rand property give map – Magnus Heystek
(Visited 38,255 times, 126 visits as of late)
